Making Millville’s High-Crime Properties Safe
I hear it a lot: “Just get rid of Section 8.” Here’s the truth. The Housing Choice Voucher (Section 8) program is federally funded and administered by state/local agencies. The city can’t ban it, and under New Jersey law landlords can’t refuse someone just because they use a voucher.
What we can do—and will do—is crack down on criminal activity at any address, voucher or not. That means enforcing code and fire laws, using nuisance-property tools, working with landlords and the housing authority on lease violations, and protecting victims who call for help.
Who suffers most from violence and chaos? The good families living on those blocks—the folks who just want to work hard, raise their kids, and sleep through the night. A small number of offenders are hurting everyone else. My plan targets those individuals and the properties that enable them, so law-abiding residents across Millville can breathe easier and take their neighborhoods back.
The city has ALL of the legal authority to facilitate all of this. It takes effort and willpower to accomplish this. Please see the EXPANDED VERSION ON MY WEBSITE for all of the legal justifications.
1. Pinpoint the hot houses. Rank the worst addresses by verified crime + code/fire hits. No rumors. No politics.
2. Show up and clamp down. Inspect, warn, and set 30-day deadlines. PD + trespass affidavits = non-tenant troublemakers removed on the spot. Victims/911 callers protected.
3. Kick out the bad actors—by the book. When evidence meets legal grounds, owners must enforce the lease. Where appropriate, HUD allows Section 8 evictions for qualifying criminal activity (we follow 24 CFR 982.310 + VAWA protections). Guests who cause chaos get banned.
4. Harden the property. Lights on. Cameras on entries. Locks fixed. Trash gone. Hazards repaired. On-site manager if needed—short, firm deadlines.
5. Hit the wallet if they stall. Daily fines. City does the work and liens the property. Licenses on probation. Repeat offenders get constant inspections.
6. If it still won’t clean up—take control.Judge can appoint a custodian/receiver, push a special tax sale, or close/board/demo if unsafe.
Enough—Millville won’t be held hostage by a handful of criminals. This plan boots the bad actors, hardens the properties they abuse, and sends the bill to them—not you. Back it, and your block gets quiet again fast—and stays that way.
See the expanded version on my website with the complete legal roadmap that we can follow.
Step 1 — Identify and legally substantiate “nuisance properties” (NJ)
A. Anchor your municipal authority (what lets us act)
- General police powers to protect health, safety, and welfare (ordinances “necessary and proper”). FindlawJustia
- Abatement & liens: Municipality may abate a nuisance/correct defects and place a municipal lien for costs. JustiaFindlaw
- Receivers/custodians for problem buildings when authorized by ordinance. JustiaFindlaw
- Unsafe/Unfit buildings (State codes):
• Uniform Construction Code (UCC)—unsafe structure notice, vacate or demolish orders. Legal Information Institute
• Uniform Fire Code (UFC)—imminent hazards & evacuation; due-process notices; appeals. NJ.govJustiaLegal Information Institute
- Abandoned Properties Rehabilitation Act (APRA): abandoned property lists, special tax sales, and receivership/rehab tools. JustiaLegal Information Institute
B. What can count as a “nuisance property” (and what to avoid)
- Serious code/fire conditions (imminent hazard, repeated UFC/UCC violations, failure to correct). Document inspections, NOVs, re-inspections. NJ.govLegal Information Institute
- Criminal nuisance conduct tied to the premises (e.g., maintaining a place for unlawful activity) with evidence—not mere rumor. Use criminal complaints/convictions where applicable. Justia+1
- APRA criteria (vacant/abandoned definitions) if we’re leveraging abandoned-property tools. Legal Information Institute
⚠️ Fair-housing guardrails (must follow):
- Do not treat arrests alone (no conviction/evidence) as proof. HUD warns that arrest-only policies and blanket criminal-history bans create FHA risk; use individualized, documented facts. HUD ArchivesFederal Register
- Do not penalize 911 calls or victims (domestic violence, stalking, disability-related crises). HUD’s nuisance guidance + VAWA protections apply; DOJ has enforced against “crime-free” schemes (Hesperia). HUD ArchiveseCFRDepartment of Justice
- Section 8 / source-of-income: NJ LAD bars discrimination based on vouchers; our criteria must be voucher-neutral. NJ.govFindlaw
C. The documentation package (build a defensible record)
- Inspection file: photos, UFC/UCC notices, time-stamped entries, compliance windows, re-inspection results. (UFC/UCC specify notice & appeal rights.) JustiaLegal Information Institute
- Police/public safety file (if relevant): incident reports or criminal complaints with underlying facts (not arrest lists). Tie conduct to the property; note outcomes. (Avoid arrest-only metrics.) HUD Archives
- Property status: APRA vacancy/abandonment factors where used. Legal Information Institute
- Ownership & registration: confirm Landlord Registration Act compliance (N.J.S.A. 46:8-27 et seq.). Non-registered owners are weaker litigants. NJ.govJustia
D. Due process (bake in fairness from the start)
- Clear notice citing the specific statute/reg (UFC 5:70-2.10) and appeal path (UFC 5:70-2.19; UCC boards). JustiaLegal Information InstituteNJ.gov
- Opportunity to cure with reasonable timelines (unless imminent hazard). NJ.gov
- Escalation ladder: re-inspect → orders → municipal abatement & lien under 40:48-2.12f/g if noncompliant. Justia+1
E. Output of Step 1 (what you’ll have in hand)
- A case file for each address meeting criteria (inspection chronologies, reports, photos, certified mailings, affidavits).
- A legal memo/checklist tying each proposed action to: UFC/UCC sections (for safety issues), 40:48-2.12f/g for abatement/liens, 2C:33-12/12.1 for criminal nuisance where charged, APRA if using abandoned-property tools, and HUD/VAWA/LAD guardrails that were applied. Legal Information Institute+1NJ.govJustia+3Justia+3Justia+3HUD ArchiveseCFRFindlaw
Step 2 — Abatement agreements + calibrated penalties (not “evict-or-be-fined”)
What you can require (safe + effective)
- Owner Abatement Agreement tied to verified problems (from Step 1): security lighting, cameras on entrances/exits, access control, trespass authorization for police, repairs to cure code/fire hazards, on-site management hours, and lawful lease enforcement where there’s documented criminal activity. Fines should attach to failure to implement these measures by deadline—not to whether a tenant is evicted. This keeps us on the right side of HUD fair-housing guidance and NJ law. HUD Archives
- Guest control without evicting the whole household: use owner “no-trespass” letters and have PD enforce New Jersey defiant trespass (2C:18-3) against non-tenant troublemakers. Findlaw
What you cannot do (or must avoid)
- No penalties for 911/EMS calls (DV, medical/mental-health, safety checks) and don’t count arrests alone. HUD has flagged both as Fair Housing Act risks; build explicit carve-outs. HUD Archives
- Don’t condition fines on “you must evict.” The city can’t compel an eviction outcome; you can only require reasonable, lawful abatement steps and cite the owner if they don’t perform them. Pair that with separate criminal/civil tools for the worst cases.
If the unit is voucher-assisted (Section 8/HCV)
Owner eviction authority exists—but must follow federal + NJ steps:
- Grounds. An owner may terminate during the lease only for: serious or repeated lease violations, violations of law related to the tenancy, or other good cause (e.g., documented criminal activity that threatens health/safety). Nonpayment by the PHA is not a ground. eCFR
- Criminal activity standard. The owner may terminate for drug-related or other threatening criminal activity even without an arrest or conviction—but to reduce FHA risk, your program should still rely on documented, verifiable conduct (police reports, founded charges, code/fire records), not raw arrests. eCFR
- Notice + PHA copy. The owner’s termination notice must state the grounds, and the owner must send a copy to the PHA; eviction can only occur by court action. eCFR
- VAWA protections. Owners/PHAs cannot penalize victims of domestic violence, dating violence, sexual assault, or stalking; lease bifurcation and other protections apply. Bake this into your forms. eCFRLegal Information Institute
What the City should do: when Step-1 evidence shows qualifying conduct, package it for the owner and PHA (incident summaries, certified orders, photos). Your abatement agreement can say “owner must lawfully enforce the lease (up to and including filing in court) ifverified conduct meets federal/NJ standards,” but the fine triggers should be tied to missed abatement actions and ongoing code/fire noncompliance, not to the eviction result itself. HUD Archives
If the unit is not voucher-assisted (most private rentals in NJ)
Evictions are governed by NJ’s Anti-Eviction Act. You can point owners to specific “good cause” grounds that match your verified issues and expect them to act lawfully:
- Disorderly conduct after “notice to cease.” (2A:18-61.1(b))
- Damage to property. (2A:18-61.1(c))
- Substantial lease or rules violations after “notice to cease.” (2A:18-61.1(d)–(e))
- Conviction-based grounds (e.g., drug offenses on or near the premises) within statutory time limits. (2A:18-61.1(n), (p)–(r))
- Notice timing (e.g., three days for disorderly/damage) flows from 2A:18-61.2 and court guidance. Owners must serve required notice to cease and notice to quit before filing. Justia Lawcityofjerseycity.com
Your SOP should say: we’ll flag the matching ground(s) for counsel, and we’ll expect owners to file only when the facts cleanly meet those grounds and notices have been served.
Penalty ladder that holds up
- Warning + abatement plan (30 days).
- Administrative fines for missed abatement tasks (not “failure to evict”).
- Enhanced inspections / license probation for rentals that don’t implement measures.
- City-performed abatement + liens under municipal nuisance powers if hazards persist.
- Receivership/custodian or criminal-nuisance action for the worst actors. (These steps are independent of a tenant’s voucher status and are anchored in code/fire and nuisance authority.) Legal Information Institute
Guardrails to print right on your forms (one-liners)
- “Emergency-call safe harbor.” Calls for police/EMS/medical/mental-health assistance, including by or for DV/SA/stalking victims, do not count as incidents and will never trigger adverse action. HUD Archives
- “Arrest-only ban.” Arrests without underlying verified conduct don’t count. We rely on documented facts. HUD Archives
- “Voucher neutrality.” City actions are voucher-neutral; NJ LAD forbids source-of-income discrimination (including HCV). NJ.gov
- “HCV eviction protocol.” For HCV cases, owners must follow 24 CFR 982.310 (grounds, written notice, copy to PHA; court action only) and honor VAWA protections in 24 CFR part 5, subpart L. eCFRLegal Information Institute
Step 3 — Enforcement track (lawful lease enforcement + court-ready files)
What triggers the eviction path (when appropriate)
- You’ve documented verified conduct at/attributable to the unit (from Step 1) and the owner has an abatement agreement (Step 2) but problems continue.
- From here, owners pursue lawful grounds under NJ or HUD rules; you keep city penalties tied to missed abatement tasks and ongoing code/fire noncompliance.
If the unit is voucher-assisted (HCV/“Section 8”)
If the unit is not voucher-assisted (most private rentals)
Guest control (when the problem is non-tenant people)
Fair-housing guardrails you must keep in Step 3 (to avoid blowback)
What the city keeps doing in Step 3 (parallel track)
Court-ready evidence package (give this to the owner/PH A or to their counsel)
- Timeline of verified incidents, copies of UFC/UCC orders, inspection notes/photos, police reports/complaints showing underlying conduct, and proof of notices to cease/quit (for NJ AEA cases) or owner’s notice + PHA copy (for HCV cases). New Jersey CourtseCFR
Step 4 — Disposition & long-term stabilization
A) Put chronic cases under a court-appointed custodian (receiver).
Adopt/trigger your local ordinance to ask the court to appoint a custodianto take charge, collect rents, make repairs, and bill costs back as a municipal lien under N.J.S.A. 40:48-2.12g. Justia LawFindlaw
B) Use the Abandoned Properties Rehabilitation Act (APRA) when it’s vacant/abandoned.
- Determine “abandoned” (≥6 months not legally occupied + statutory conditions) and place on the Abandoned Property List; then you can pursue rehab/possession or special tax sale. N.J.S.A. 55:19-81 (definition), 55:19-55 (list/authority), 55:19-101 (special tax sale). Justia Law+1NJSL Legislative Histories
- APRA gives a structured path to transfer control to a responsible party or push rehab under court supervision. Justia Law
C) If it’s truly unsafe, repair/close or demolish with lien.
When a building is unfit or unsafe, you can order repair, closure, or demolition and lien the costs under Title 40’s unfit-building powers (N.J.S.A. 40:48-2.3; 40:48-2.5/-2.5a). Use UCC/UFC findings to document the hazard. Justia Law+1
D) Recover every dollar (and change ownership incentives).
All city-performed abatement/board-up/repair costs attach as municipal liensunder 40:48-2.12f; unpaid liens position you for disposition through tax sale or APRA routes. Justia LawFindlaw
E) Stabilize the block so problems don’t rebound.
- Require post-rehab security & CPTED fixes (lighting, access control, cameras at entries) through the abatement agreement or as certificate-of-occupancy conditions under your police powers (40:48-1, -2). Justia Law+1
- Move cooperative owners to a higher rental-license tier (fewer inspections/lower fees); keep chronic actors on probation with audits—again under 40:48-1, -2. Justia Law
Key links (for counsel and staff)
- Custodian/receiver: 40:48-2.12g — law.justia.com ✔ Justia Law
- Municipal abate & lien: 40:48-2.12f — law.justia.com ✔ Justia Law
- APRA (abandoned): 55:19-81 (definition), 55:19-55 (list), 55:19-101 (special tax sale) — law.justia.com / NJ legislature ✔ Justia Law+1NJSL Legislative Histories
- Unsafe/Imminent hazard codes: UCC 5:23-2.32; UFC 5:70-2.16 — Cornell LII ✔ Legal Information Institute+1
- Unfit/unsafe demolition authority: 40:48-2.3, -2.5/-2.5a — law.justia.com ✔ Justia Law+1
- General police powers (to run your tiered licensing & CPTED conditions): 40:48-1, -2 — law.justia.com ✔ Justia Law+1
Step 5 — Oversight, transparency, and sustainment (12-month loop)
1) Publish + meet by the book.
- Run a quarterly public scorecard (aggregated stats only) and handle records under OPRA as amended (P.L. 2024, c.16); use the GRC’s updated text/guide so your templates match the new rules. NJ.gov+1
- If a board/commission is taking action (vs. staff-only case huddles), notice and conduct meetings per the Open Public Meetings Act (OPMA). NJ.govNew Jersey State Library
2) Civil-rights & fair-housing audit (at least annually).
- Check outcomes for disparate impact under FHA (the 3-step standard in 24 CFR 100.500); adjust thresholds/definitions if any protected group is being hit harder without a strong, necessary justification. eCFRLegal Information Institute
- Confirm your nuisance program follows HUD’s 2016 guidance (don’t count 911/EMS calls; don’t rely on arrest-only data). HUD Archives
- Re-verify VAWA protections are honored for survivors in HUD-assisted housing (lease bifurcation, emergency transfers, confidentiality). eCFRLegal Information Institute
- Reaffirm NJ LAD compliance, including source-of-lawful-income (voucher) protection—keep everything voucher-neutral. NJ.gov
3) Annual training & SOP refresh.
Train police/code/fire/landlord-licensing staff and participating landlords on: (a) your carve-outs (DV/medical/mental-health calls), (b) “documented conduct, not arrests,” (c) HCV eviction rules/VAWA, and (d) OPRA/OPMA handling for case files. Point the materials to the HUD + CFR sources above. HUD ArchiveseCFR
4) Funding the work (so it’s not a paper tiger).
Use CDBG where eligible: code enforcement in deteriorating areas (24 CFR 570.202(c)) and clearance/demolition (24 CFR 570.201(d)). That can cover inspection salaries, legal proceedings for enforcement (not repairs), and unsafe-structure clearance. eCFR+1
5) Data governance & privacy.
Publish only aggregated, de-identified address stats; release underlying records through OPRA with required redactions (use the GRC’s updated materials). Keep case-conference huddles staff-level to avoid OPMA unless a public body is deliberating. NJ.gov
6) Annual ordinance tune-up.
With counsel, adjust point thresholds, incident definitions, and timelines using your audit results; reaffirm citations to UFC/UCC, nuisance-abatement/liens, and receivership so your authority chain is crystal clear. Tie these updates to a brief public memo citing the sources above. HUD ArchiveseCFR
General police power & abatement/liens
- https://codes.findlaw.com/nj/title-40-municipalities-and-counties/nj-st-sect-40-48-2/
- https://law.justia.com/codes/new-jersey/title-40/section-40-48-2-12f/
- https://law.justia.com/codes/new-jersey/title-40/section-40-48-2-12g/
Uniform Fire Code (UFC)
- https://www.law.cornell.edu/regulations/new-jersey/N-J-A-C-5-70-2-16
- https://regulations.justia.com/states/new-jersey/title-5/chapter-70/subchapter-2/section-5-70-2-10/
- https://www.law.cornell.edu/regulations/new-jersey/N-J-A-C-5-70-2-19
Uniform Construction Code (UCC)
- https://www.law.cornell.edu/regulations/new-jersey/N-J-A-C-5-23-2-32
- https://regulations.justia.com/states/new-jersey/title-5/chapter-23/subchapter-2/
APRA (Abandoned Properties)
- https://law.justia.com/codes/new-jersey/title-55/section-55-19-98/
- https://law.justia.com/codes/new-jersey/title-55/section-55-19-101/
Criminal nuisance statutes
- https://law.justia.com/codes/new-jersey/title-2c/section-2c-33-12/
- https://law.justia.com/codes/new-jersey/title-2c/section-2c-33-12-1/
Landlord registration (NJ)
- https://www.nj.gov/dca/codes/publications/pdf_lti/landlord_idnty_law.pdf
- https://law.justia.com/codes/new-jersey/title-46/section-46-8-27/
Fair housing guardrails
- HUD nuisance/crime-free guidance (2016): https://archives.hud.gov/news/2016/pr16-134-FinalNuisanceOrdGdnce.pdf
- HUD criminal-records guidance (2016): https://www.hud.gov/sites/documents/HUD_OGCGUIDAPPFHASTANDCR.PDF
- VAWA housing regs: https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-24/subtitle-A/part-5/subpart-L
- DOJ–Hesperia settlement (crime-free ordinance): https://www.justice.gov/archives/opa/pr/justice-department-secures-landmark-agreement-city-and-police-department-ending-crime-free
- NJ LAD—source of lawful income: https://www.nj.gov/dca/home/discrimination.shtml ; https://codes.findlaw.com/nj/title-10-civil-rights/nj-st-sect-10-5-12/
Core municipal tools (New Jersey)
Tenant-facing guardrails you need on the face of your forms
How Step 2 interfaces with actual evictions (when appropriate)
Practical guest control (without evicting the household)
What these citations let you do (cleanly)
- Write Owner Abatement Agreements that require: lighting/cameras, access control, trespass authorization, property management hours, code/fire corrections, and lawful lease enforcement when verified conduct meets state/federal standards. Fines attach to missed abatement milestones (and ongoing UFC/UCC noncompliance), not to eviction outcomes. Justia Law+2Justia Law+2Legal Information InstituteNJ.gov
- Bake in safe harbors: emergency-call immunity and DV/SA protections (VAWA), no arrest-only metrics, voucher neutrality (NJ LAD). These are straight from HUD/DOJ/NJ sources above. HUD ArchiveseCFR+1NJ.gov